




e their lands. The fact that you disagree or agree does not prevent that it is their rights. Discussion is rather on the way used to achieve their goals, but again we should ask us: Have they other choice? I could be interessting to see what people think about it.
By examining and analysing the utilisation of Islamic religion by two political parties, the Hamas and the Hezbollah, through their political agendas, I will show that these two groups are islamist but not terrorist.
A. The goals and the place of religion in the Hezbollah’s ideology at the moment of its creation.
B. Since its creation does Hezbollah has increased or decreased the religious influence through its politics?
II. Does the controversial political party in power in
A. When Hamas was created, did it include religious ambitions?
B. Does the place of religion have changed in the Hamas’ politics since its creation?
II. How those 2 political parties are seen in the world?
A. The perception of Hamas and Hezbollah in western press especially in the north American press
B. The perception of Hamas and Hezbollah in the Middle eastern press
Since the events of the September
The influence and the creation of Hamas do not generally carry divided ideas through works made. Indeed, like many other authors, Matthew Levitt, who is a specialist of the question of terrorism at the Washington Institute for the Near East Policy, considers Muslim Brotherhood as the main influence of Hamas (30-31). The Muslim Brotherhood is an islamist group which has as credo, “God is our objective, the Quran is our Constitution.”[i] The most controversial points are the definition of its goals and the definition of the status of the group. By studying the goals of Hamas, we notice that this question has several answer s. As Levitt explains it in his book Hamas, the main goal of Hamas is dawa (calling people to God) and thus, he considers Hamas as an islamist group (16). In the article of Andrea Nüsse, who is a report in the Muslim world and who has a diploma in Arabic and Middle Eastern Studies, reveals another goal. Indeed, for her, the goal of the islamist group Hamas is to liberate the
Like for Hamas, there are many definitions to describe Hezbollah. Homayra says in his article Hezbollah- Terrorist Group or Political Party that this organization is “broad-based political party.” He remains the fact that Hezbollah “has not been involved in deliberate attacks on civilians since the end of the civil war” (1). According to Elaine Pasquini’s article, “Hezbollah is a multidimensional organization which has political and social aspects”. Neil MacFarquar, the correspondent of The New York Times in Middle East, designs Hezbollah as a militant organization contrary to the
Ronald Nettler, in his article, affirms that for islamist groups, Islam is a, “particular sort of polity and society, through which religion is most perfectly expressed in accord with the divine will” (50). For him, any Islamic government form exists and the Quran could not be use as a constitution simply because Quran is not a constitution. The author even says that islamist groups of today bring and coerce Muslim to follow “rigid political arrangement […] with some of tradition’s now irrelevant” (55). In Salwa Ismail article, we read that again Islam is the first concept of identity, and then gender, class and national identity are secondary (615). She also tries to show that Islamists try to make a unity with politics and religion. She compares the influence of Islamic faith on political groups in Middle East to the “Moral Majority” in the
Indeed, there are researches about Hezbollah and Hamas. There are researches about Islamism; however, there seem to have no research done the impact of Islamic faith on Hezbollah and on Hamas’s politics, which it will be my research paper’s thesis statement. The subject, as we saw, brings a lot of controversial issues like to usually simple task to define an organization. Moreover, because the subject touches political and religious aspect, some author could have a biased approach. What could be interesting it to see the way the subject is treated by Muslim and Arabic authors. I say this because I read that the term Islamism was invented in Western to analyse the Muslim world and thus, the term is maybe not used by Muslim and Arabic authors.
My research paper will talk about two important political organizations in Middle-East: the Hamas and the Hezbollah. Islamism is a new movement which is more and more often put in the headlines. Thus, in my research paper, I will try to demonstrate that Islamic faith has an impact on the politics of these two political organizations which are the Hamas, a Palestinian party, and the Hezbollah, a Lebanese party. By the same way, I will try to make understand to my readers that an Islamist organization does not mean a terrorist organization.
Approach:
In my research paper, I will try to establish a relationship between Islamic religion and politics of these two parties. I will also make a contrast and comparisons between American (Time) and Canadian (The Globe and Mail) press with
Because my audience does not necessary knows Islam and some of its notions, I will have to make a short historic of this religion and also, I will have to include some definitions in an appendix. I will do also the same for the two parties studied, Hamas and Hezbollah.
I think my topic worth to be considering because we heard everyday about terrorist attacks, about Muslim world, about the relationship between the
First, I will have to read many articles from different points of view. I will take notes from them. Afterwards, I will analyse my readings to the most objective as possible. Lastly, I will explain how the Islamic religion is used in Hezbollah and Hamas’ politics.
1.1 Its creation
1.2 Its goals
1.3 Its activities
1.4 The religious implication
2.1 Its creation
2.2 Its goals
2.3 Its activities
2.4 The religious implications
Part 3: Contrast and comparison of the two parties in the press (Canadian-American vs. Middle Eastern)
In this article, the author explains that the fact that some Sunni leaders blamed Hezbollah comes not from the difference religious beliefs, but comes from the fear of seeing other groups becoming powerful. Face to American influence in the region and face to Israeli policies, there is no more "Pan-Arab" or "Pan-Muslim" solidarity. Among people, it does not matter if Hezbollah or Palestinian victims are Sunni or Shia.
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1540-5842.2006.00845.x?journalCode=npqu
Title: The Unholy
Author: Tanveer Ahmed
In this article, Ahmed explains that the increasing number of supporter of new islamlist organisations and of supporters of the resurgence of Islam is due to the fact that Islamic religion supports poor and oppressed.
Policy Magazine Vo. 22 No. 4 Summer 2006-2007
Title: Hezbollah Is Not a Puppet of
Author: Reza Aslan
The author concluded here that
http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1540-5842.2006.00843.x
Title: Religion and Civil Society: Whiter Political Islam?
According to this article, Hezbollah has gained power and supporters because it helps people by building school and providing help to the population, and in a better way than the
http://nvs.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/28/1/83.pdf
First, I wanted my research to be about the relationship between
I am still quite not sure of the approach that I will choose. I would like to examine the situation and the sources fro, finally, analysing the data to make my own explication of the situation. However, I will also contract the situation presented in international press versus western press.
Because my audience not necessary knows Islam and some of its notions, I will have to make a short historic of this religion and also, I will have to include some definitions. I will do also the same for the two organisations studied, Hamas and Hezbollah.
It is so easy to explain my interest to this subject because I am fascinated by everything that touches the Arab and Muslim world. Since I am 15 years old, I read and try to learn more and more about this. I try to see the world from a different point of view. I made a wonderful trip in
I think my topic worth to be considering because we heard everyday about terrorists attacks, about Muslim world, about the relationship between the
My steps to make this research is combined with analyse and historic. Indeed, as I said before, historic of Islam, Hamas, Hezbollah and
Islamic faith and politics: case of
Part 1: Historic and definitions
1.1: Islam
A little historic of the religion and definitions of specific notions and vocabulary related to this religion.
1.2: Hamas
A little historic and definitions of notions apply by Hamas.
1.3 Hezbollah
A little historic and definitions of notions apply by Hezbollah.
1.4
A little historic of Iranian politics in the 20th century and explanation of some specifics notions.
Part 2: Contrast of the subject in international press versus North American press.
Part 3: Analyse of the situation
Because my research will include some notion of the Islamic religion, I thought that it could be a good idea to make a little historic, and to add few definitions related to Islam which is often, unfortunately, related to violence, oppression, extremism and which is the aim of several prejudices.
Historic:
In 610, Muhammad (peace be upon him), the prophet of Islam and the last of the three monotheist religions, received the first revelations from God through the angel Gabriel, which is the same angel that appeared to Mary. It was on the
eginning of the Islamic era and the beginning of the Islamic calendar. The reason of the persecution was that
Like in Christianism, there are division in the islamic religion. The 2 mains are: Sunni and Shi'a. Mostly, 85% of Muslims are Sunni. The division came mainly from the fact that when Muhammad (pbuh) died; according to Sunni there was no sucessor apointed. According to Shia, the prophet (pbuh) apointed Ali, his cousin, to be the sucessor. Finally, Abu Bakr became the Caliph, which means the leader. There are differences in rituals, in fiqh (islamic law), in beliefs, in historic aspects.
Islam: the religion
Islamic: this is an adjective of something which is related to Islam: Islamic history, Islamic religion, Islamic Law.
Muslim: a person who is an adherant to Islam. Be carefull to do not mix with islamist.
Islamist: a person who use the religion with political goals.
Islamism: the ideology that Islam should be a political systems; taking the religion as an instrument to reach some poilitcal goals and often in an extremist way.
Jihad: It means literally effort. In Islam, the effort can be personnal (for exemple, honesty) and can be common, like defending the religion and dignity. This term is unfortunately translated as "holywar" compared with the Christiant Crusades, which does not exist in this from in Islam.
Source: http://www.claybennett.com/images/archivetoons/islam.jpg
My research paper will talk about a subject which is very topical. The war between Hezbollah and